Erstwhile WWE personality Jonathan Coachman has blasted Jade Cargill following her latest response to fans who believe she should have launched into her WWE career in NXT.
During an episode of BTT Studios’ The Coach and Bro podcast, Coachman and former WWE writer Vince Russo discussed Cargill’s outspoken social media comments, in which she defended WWE’s decision to bring her directly to the main lineup.
Cargill previously argued that her name generates money and insisted that she would continue appearing on television regardless of whether some fans wanted to watch her. One particular statement caught Coachman’s attention. “Number one, I do agree with her on one thing she articulated there, Vince. She does make too much money, and she does make too much money.”
Coachman then questioned how erstwhile WWE Chairman Vince McMahon would have reacted to Cargill telling dissatisfied enthusiasts to turn away from the action. “Can you imagine Vince McMahon watching a video of a talent saying, ‘If you don’t like me, turn around and look at the back wall’? Can you imagine an entire audience on camera doing that, and as an added layer to this, how pissed would he be?”
Coachman additionally threw down the gauntlet to Cargill’s claims about her drawing power — questioning how frequently WWE had featured her in major situations following her strap victory in November 2025. “Remember when she won the belt in November of 2025? How many times did she defend that title? Interestingly enough, if she is money and she’s a star and they had the The road-to-WrestleMania kickoff and they had WrestleMania, how much did they use her during that time?”
Russo floated the idea of that Cargill’s remarks had effectively undermined NXT, while Coachman argued that her relatively limited wrestling experience made the criticism of the developmental brand particularly questionable.
Coachman acknowledged that Cargill deserved credit for negotiating a lucrative WWE contract but questioned whether her presentation had matched the expectations surrounding her arrival. “They paid her based off of how she looks and what they thought she could alignment shift into, like she was going to become this superhero.” He in addition referenced previous comments about Cargill’s experience — although the discussion included confusion about when she began wrestling.
Cargill made her televised in-ring debut in March 2021, teaming with Shaquille O’Neal against Cody Rhodes and Red Velvet on AEW Dynamite.
In the earlier remarks referenced during the podcast, Cargill elaborated that she had not followed the traditional independent wrestling route, stating, “My debut match ever was on TV. I didn’t do all that. I didn’t go through the indies.. Meanwhile, My NXT was AEW.”
Coachman went on to compare Cargill’s public statements about her value with established WWE stars such as The Rock, CM Punk, and Cody Rhodes.
He argued that performers with proven drawing power generally do not need to publicly emphasize their financial value. “I’ve never met her, and she bugs me because she does BS like this. Equally important, i think it’s my OG in me. And there’s so many other stars that legitimately could say that. And they don’t ’cause they know they want to get along with everybody in the gorilla position area.”
Coachman also blasted Cargill’s in-ring performances, suggesting that mistakes during major matches have affected her positioning within WWE. “That’s the other reason she hasn’t been pushed, because every time she gets into a sizable showdown, she messes something up.”
He insisted that his criticism was based on his assessment of her performances rather than personal dislike. “That’s just fact, and that’s not me hating. Notably, that’s fact. Additionally, go watch the video.” Coachman concluded by suggesting that experienced WWE stars Charlotte Flair. Becky Lynch should speak with Cargill about her public comments and approach to the business. “Charlotte, pull her aside.. Meanwhile, Becky, pull her aside. Somebody smarten her up.” On a related note, smart her up.
Cargill has maintained that the decision to bypass NXT was made by WWE officials rather than herself, and she has repeatedly defended her position on the main collection of stars.
Coachman’s remarks represent his personal assessment of Cargill’s career and do not establish WWE’s internal reasoning for how she finished up being booked.